The resistance of steel skeletons against earthquakes is a critical topic in structural engineering and building design. Given the occurrence of severe earthquakes in various regions, the importance of this subject becomes evident. Due to their unique characteristics, steel skeletons are considered one of the top options for constructing buildings. If you also intend to build a steel skeleton, you can benefit from the services of Saman Dezh. For more information, feel free to contact us right now.
Comparison of Steel and Concrete Skeletons in Terms of Earthquake Resistance
When choosing the type of skeleton for construction, there are two main options: steel skeletons and concrete skeletons. Each of these types has its specific features, advantages, and disadvantages, which we will compare below.
Weight and Lightness
- Steel Skeleton: Steel skeletons are generally lighter than concrete skeletons. This feature reduces the load on the building’s foundation and requires less substructure.
- Concrete Skeleton: This type of skeleton is heavier and, therefore, requires more precise design for the foundation and substructure.
➕ Flexibility and Earthquake Resistance
➕ Construction Speed
- Steel Skeleton: The construction and installation of steel skeletons are usually faster than concrete due to their prefabricated nature and lightness.
- Concrete Skeleton: The process of constructing concrete skeletons takes more time and requires longer drying and curing periods.
➕Costs
- Steel Skeleton: Initial costs may be higher, but due to the speed of construction and reduced project time, the overall costs may be lower.
- Concrete Skeleton: Initial construction costs may be lower, but the longer project duration can increase final costs.
➕ Durability and Maintenance
- Steel Skeleton: If properly treated against rust and protected, steel skeletons can be very durable. However, they are vulnerable to corrosion.
- Concrete Skeleton: Concrete has high durability and requires less maintenance, but repairs can be challenging in case of cracking.
➕Aesthetics
- Steel Skeleton: Due to modern designs and attractive appearances, steel skeletons are often more popular in contemporary projects.
- Concrete Skeleton: While it can contribute to the simplicity and strength of a building, it may not be as visually appealing as steel skeletons.
Read More: Understanding Steel Skeletons in Warehouses
The Resistance of Steel Buildings
✅ Engineering Design
Proper and precise design is one of the most critical factors in determining the earthquake resistance of steel buildings. Engineers should utilize modern software and reputable standards for analysis and design to ensure that the structure can effectively withstand seismic loads.
✅ Type and Quality of Materials
The use of high-quality and suitable materials significantly impacts the strength of the building. The steel used in constructing the steel skeleton must be verified for its strength and flexibility.
✅ Geological Conditions and Project Location
The geographical location and soil type also play a role in the resistance of steel buildings. In areas with a high risk of earthquakes, design and construction must be conducted with greater care.
✅ Seismic Load
The level of seismic load, which is calculated based on local standards, affects the design. Steel buildings are designed to withstand seismic forces of up to 7 Richter or even higher.
Read More: Guidelines for Painting Steel Skeletons
Use of Resilient Systems
➕ Bending Resistance Systems
These systems typically include beams and columns specifically designed to withstand bending loads. In this system, the structural members are arranged to effectively absorb and distribute seismic forces.
➕ Shear Resistance Systems
Shear systems usually consist of shear walls or shear panels placed along the building. These walls act as a resistant element and transfer lateral loads to the ground. This type of system is especially effective in tall buildings.
➕ Combined Resistance Systems
A combination of bending and shear systems can contribute to designing a more resilient structure. These types of systems improve the overall performance of the building against earthquakes by combining the advantages of both methods.
➕ Use of Dampers
Dampers, known as energy-absorbing elements, can be effective in reducing vibrations caused by earthquakes. These systems absorb seismic energy and prevent it from being transmitted to the building.
➕ Advanced Resistance Systems
The use of modern technologies, such as active and semi-active systems, is also expanding in the design of earthquake-resistant buildings. These systems automatically respond to changes in load and can provide better performance under critical conditions.
Choosing between steel and concrete frames depends on the specific needs and conditions of the project. Both types of frames have their unique advantages and disadvantages, and decision-making should be based on factors such as cost, construction time, geographical conditions, and performance requirements. The use of resistance systems in building design plays a crucial role in enhancing safety and durability. With the appropriate selection and design of these systems, resilient structures against earthquakes and other lateral forces can be achieved.
Read More: Construction of Steel Frame with Bolts
